wts ur opinion abt reservation in education centers?

badshaah · Been around a while Joined: 23 Mar 2006 Posts: 31

Do u support the reservation in education centers ?

suresh_ktnv · Joined: 07 Apr 2006 Posts: 5

Not at all. There is no reservations in IITs. Then only IITs stands for MERIT. Otherwise there is no difference between ordinary colleges and IITs
K T N V suresh

ved · Joined: 10 Apr 2006 Posts: 11 Location: bangalore

ajit1 · Posted: Mon Apr 10, 2006 1:13 pm Post subject: RESERVATIONS

hi

Guys leave abt hte affordibilty issue of the students who make it.. its clearly mentioned that once a student clears fees is not a contrain for any1. Even IIMS says thisvery explicitly in their prospectus
where does the question of reservations come .. when will our govt strt behaving in a immature manner . Why do OBC ans ST/ SC students accept there reforms .. dont you all have the guts and chanllege to make it the way otheres do .What financial problem is there in filling a form of costs harldy few hundreds or thousand.
Let govt make some financial reforms rather than taking reservation issues. Its jus nonsense and hurts for students who struggle so hard to get into scuh prestigious institutions

shagun · Joined: 21 Mar 2006 Posts: 18

what does our constitution say all should be treated equally so WHY RESERVATIONS.
dont u think this step is dividing further and creating a feeling of hostility.

Goverments responsibility is to give primary and secondary education to all so that they strengthen the base of minorities.Reserving seats for them wont help.Many students belonging to general category cannot afford good education so what abt them.
what i dont understand is the question should be whether someone is able to afford education or not so he should be given some priviledge irrespective of the cast/Category
but here what is happening is being a minority whether rich or poor u r getting priviledge.is it fair
Admission to premier institutes is highly competitive and a large number of students are left out because they have been born in a general category . they work very very hard today because of cut throat competion so that would lead to mental depression of those deserving students.
politicians use reservations for their political gains and create divisions between the communities. But they are not aware that what it feels to be left out inspite of being good academicaly but bcoz of limited seats.
And also with time these premier institutes would degrade as the students would not be admitted based on their merit but on their castes.

ajit1 · Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2006 1:41 pm Post subject: good one

appreciate your points shagun very neatly presented

amlanchatterjee · Joined: 13 Apr 2006 Posts: 1

hi friends amlan hear..
nice to know de thoughts of all u guys on reserviation............i totally agree with u all guys......what i see as the benifits of reservation are:
1 The bifarcation of the society.........
2Filling the vote bank of Govrment.........
3Degradtion on the level of education quality''''
4big industry leaders have just commended it.........

I feel we all should just it oppose and do all possible help to the people working in disfavoring it.

gokul · Joined: 08 May 2006 Posts: 6

I doubt the very objective of the congress led government in the central as their main objective was to make India a more secular country. Don’t they think by introducing the caste based reservation system, they are making fissures in the young minds of India. Once these methods of reservation are introduced it will become difficult to remove this from our society. because, Again the removal of this reservation will face a similar
Disturbing violence in the country. Don’t the congress feel they are defeating there objective by the name of reservation.

when Mr. Manmohan Singh is talking about free trade area, a Level Playing Ground for both Domestic and Internal players why cant we have a Level playing ground in the education sector. I wonder how the same government is playing contradictory roles. I thing the government should define its objectives very clearly.

I agree with what Montyistic said as we should put more efforts to improve the Primary, and secondary since they forms the fundamental education. The government must give free education to the poor people, they should be trained separately, more efforts have to be laid on them and they should be tested with all others.

deepu · Posted: Fri Aug 04, 2006 6:13 pm Post subject:

No I do not support reservations in the educational instituitions.Because If you say run 200 meters in just one hour and you will be given the first prize.The person will practice in accord to that only.Which is decreasing the standard.In the present case the person who is provided with reservation is getting the similar favour.In accord to that he will prepare and he will enjoy the rest of time.Instead giving favours in the form of marks and performance give the backword people the enough money to get through the educational system.And then collect from him.Let the backword cast people get reservations in the rates of interest and the amount of money that can be provided.

dilip kumar · Joined: 07 Aug 2007 Posts: 1 Location: HYD

bhaveshshah · Joined: 07 Mar 2007 Posts: 3

Hi friends i think today we can see that our country is not fully developed so we should not remove reservation completely because much of the good and brillient student requires it. Reservation should be based on the criteria of the economic position of the perticular not on the basis of the casts because in one cast one cant determine that all are economically disable to fulfill the requirements of the student.